July
To do: start working on your college list! Here’s how to build it!
NOTE: This is A LOT to do in a month. Try to get through as much as you can with your mentee, but don’t sweat if you don’t make it through - you can keep working on this in August!
[1] Make a big, inclusive list
Make a list of schools they're interested in applying to - this can include any schools you are even tangentially interested in
What other kinds of colleges should you consider?
HBCU? (see addendum at end)
Women’s college? (see addendum at end)
Other colleges that your college access person/teachers/friends have recommended?
Explore some of these colleges that might have a program for you:
Does it have your major, or something major-adjacent?
Eg. med school/nursing/PA - you can major in bio
Eg. physical therapy - science-heavy curriculum will get you there
MAKE SURE YOU ARE NOT PICKING A MAJOR and then only applying to schools with that major!
Remember major-adjacent is often enough!
Historically, students in college change their majors often, and if you lock into a specific college that has a specific major but not a lot of other options, you will not be able to change your mind later
Students are more likely to drop out if they can’t switch to something that seems better when they find (especially in STEM, which our students often are not adequately prepared for) that they are struggling academically in college - which almost everyone does (it’s normal if you do!)
Remember that there is no way any human can accurately predict at 16 what they’d like to spend the rest of their lives doing. We need to make sure students have room to change their minds as they get more information about what they’re good at and what they want to do.
Look at the regional and demographic-specific resources:
[2] Narrow your big list: academics + fit
Get the GPA and SAT score of each college
check Naviance to see if anyone from the student’s school has applied and if so, did they get in (at what GPA/SAT score)
FYI: Colleges really want to support our students.
Our students will be competitive with GPAs .1-.3 points lower than what’s listed as “average”
unweighted, on a 4.0 scale. Most GPAs are out of 4.0; if you don’t know what it’s out of, it probably is out of 4.0
Our students will be competitive with SAT scores 150-200 points lower than what’s listed as “average”
NYS - HEOP: do you qualify financially?
Weigh your options: yes to ED1, ED2, EA or regular?
Does your school offer ED or EA?
Only apply to ED if:
You will have 100% of your need met by the school and you have a $0 family contribution
You can pay for college no matter what amount of aid you receive
Are there fly-in programs in the fall you should attend? https://www.appily.com/guidance/counselors/college-greenlight/fly-in-and-diversity-programs
Think about each school from the following metrics - what do you want?
Big/small/medium
how large do you want your classes to be?
Do you want your professors to help you out when you need it - to know you and maybe offer before you have to ask?
Rural/urban/suburban
Region/distance from home (incl in-state/out-of-state)
Weather/temperature
Greek/non-greek
Identify if your schools are PWIs and make sure you’re ready for that, if they are
How much you’ll make after you graduate + networking/connections:
how much you’ll make after you graduate: https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/
alumni networks (getting you a $$ job): https://www.collegeconsensus.com/rankings/best-college-alumni-networks/
emerging industries: https://www.collegevaluesonline.com/colleges-with-industry-connections/
Public/private, 2 year vs 4 year
Think about the amount of money you need/you can pay/if you’re likely to go to a highly selective/what your GPA is
If your GPA is below a 2.5, think about a community college and transfer to a 4-year later, when you have some classes under your belt that demonstrate that you’re able to work hard and get good grades
If your GPA is between 2.5-3.2, think public in-state
If your GPA is between 3.0-3.5, you might have a shot at private or an honors college - look at this list: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1MEOIwjhoEBL0074yyRDokyUNXReeCTQDzLdgydsFNCw/edit?gid=0#gid=0
If your GPA is above 3.5, look for a school that meets 100% of need
EXCEPTION: HEOP programs - can be as low as a 73 (out of 100) GPA
Learn about the colleges you’re interested in:
Visit!
Read student reviews of that college:
Niche - google “college name + niche + reviews”
Question: Should I apply only to test-optional colleges?
Our policy: take the SAT and see what you get on it
If you hate your scores (and remember that they can be lower than what’s posted), apply for test-optional schools!
Test-optional schools - the definitive list: https://fairtest.org/test-optional-list/
[3] Narrow your big list: Financial need
Do the net price calculator for each school!
Do the (formerly known as) FAFSA 4Caster: https://studentaid.gov/aid-estimator/
Get your SAI (student aid index; formerly EFC): https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/pay-for-college/get-started/financial-aid-quiz
How much can you pay?
Does your EFC match up with how much you/your family can actually pay?
You likely will need scholarships
Identify: Can you apply to schools that meet 100% of need? These are highly selective schools - you need above a 3.5 unweighted to apply.
List of schools that meet 100% of need: https://blog.collegevine.com/schools-that-meet-100-percent-financial-need
To figure out how much need a school meets and what the breakdown of loans/grants is:
Go to College Board’s Big Future: https://bigfuture.collegeboard.org/
Type in the name of the school you’re interested in in the search bar
Click on “Costs” on the top menu bar
Look at:
“Distribution Details”
Freshmen With Need and Received Financial Aid
Percent of Need Met
“Aid Package Details”
Look at the percentage of scholarship vs loan amount
[4] Create your list: minimum requirements
Include targets, reaches, and safeties
targets: 5
reaches: 3 up to as many as you want
safeties: 3
All schools on this list should be financially feasible for both you & your family!
You should be willing, if not excited, to attend EVERY SCHOOL on this list. Because you might have to.
[5] Addendum: Specific college types to consider
Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs)
Very different from other school experiences: know if you want that experience
Do your research: try to talk to students at both
List of HBCUs, organized by state: https://hbculifestyle.com/hbcu-colleges-list/
Look at the money: https://www.instagram.com/hbcumoneyguide/?hl=en
Pros:
Sense of community
Doing things with people who get you - will understand what you’re going through
Can give you more confidence/don’t have to deal with as many racist views/microaggressions as you might at a predominantly white institutions (PWI)
Inspirational to see other people of color succeeding and thriving
More professors of color, read more works from scholars of color
Women’s colleges
Very different from other school experiences: know if you want that experience
Do your research: try to talk to students at women’s colleges List of women’s colleges: http://www.womenscolleges.org/colleges
Pros:
Surrounded by women supporting other women
Sense of community and collaboration
More of a focus on LGBTQ
Amazing network post-college
Resources from mentor training:
Introductory slide deck for Yleana college access mentors: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1Vw9mN2QdZ9k7QdVQpHUj0OHSdIAj_A7XThYAYtYjHNw/edit?usp=sharing
Connecting with your mentee: https://yleana.org/college-access/connecting-with-your-mentee
College Access training video recording
From the July 2nd mentor training session: https://app.fireflies.ai/view/2024-Yleana-College-Access-Mentoring-Training-3::xwFRASlG9TEesy6O